Gareth Southgate’s legacy as England manager is one of progress and near misses. While he leaves with a better record than any manager since Sir Alf Ramsey, he fell short of delivering the major trophies England craved.
Southgate’s tenure saw England consistently reach the latter stages of major tournaments, a stark contrast to the embarrassing exits under previous managers. Despite restoring England as a serious contender on the global stage, Southgate’s inability to lead the team to victory in four major tournaments left a lingering sense of unfulfilled potential.
The close-but-not-quite-there theme of Southgate’s time as manager earned him the reputation of an “almost England manager” leading an “almost England team.” His near misses in the World Cup and Euros finals highlighted occasional tactical shortcomings and a perceived lack of flexibility in crucial moments.
However, Southgate’s impact on the English national team extended beyond the pitch. His calm and measured demeanor, along with his willingness to address societal issues like racism, endeared him to fans and players alike. Southgate’s leadership off the field, coupled with his efforts to make the England team more accessible to the media and fans, transformed the team’s image.
Despite facing personal abuse and doubts about his managerial decisions, Southgate’s commitment to building a cohesive team and fostering young talent was evident throughout his tenure. His willingness to make tough decisions, such as dropping key players like Wayne Rooney and Raheem Sterling, showcased his resolve and determination to put the team’s interests first.
Southgate’s legacy will be defined by his ability to steer England through a period of transition and restore faith in the national team. While he may not have delivered the elusive major trophy, Southgate leaves behind a team that is better positioned for success in the future.
As England looks to build on Southgate’s foundation, the search for a new manager will undoubtedly be a challenging task. Finding a successor who can carry on Southgate’s legacy of progress and unity will be crucial in maintaining England’s status as a competitive force in international football.