Cam Newton is widely regarded as one of the greatest dual-threat quarterbacks in NFL history, with many considering him the best. However, when asked about his place among the greats, Newton humbly deferred to Lamar Jackson, acknowledging Jackson’s unique style of play and exceptional speed. Newton highlighted Jackson’s ability to make big plays at any moment and his unmatched speed on the field. Newton recognized that while he played the game with power, he might get caught when running, unlike Vick and Jackson who are known for their elusive speed.
The debate over who is the greatest dual-threat quarterback in NFL history is a long and ongoing one, especially as the game continues to evolve, and running quarterbacks become more common. To better understand this debate, we can divide the discussion into two eras: the scrambling era (pre-2000) and the dual-threat era (post-2000).
In the scrambling era, quarterbacks like Steve Young, Fran Tarkenton, Randall Cunningham, John Elway, and Tobin Rote stood out for their ability to both run and pass effectively. Young, in particular, was known for his excellence as both a runner and a passer, leading the league in various passing categories and setting a high standard for future dual-threat quarterbacks. Tarkenton, despite not winning a Super Bowl, was a prolific passer and rusher, setting records for passing yards and touchdowns. Cunningham, dubbed “The Ultimate Weapon,” was ahead of his time with his rushing abilities and paved the way for future dual-threat quarterbacks. Elway, known for his clutch performances and scrambling ability, led the Broncos to two Super Bowl victories. Rote, while not as well-known, was a trailblazer for scrambling quarterbacks in the early days of the NFL.
In the dual-threat era post-2000, quarterbacks like Michael Vick, Cam Newton, Lamar Jackson, Josh Allen, and Russell Wilson have redefined the position with their ability to both run and pass effectively. Vick, in particular, changed the game with his speed and agility, setting records for rushing yards by a quarterback. Newton, the former MVP, set records for rushing touchdowns and combined passing and rushing touchdowns in a season. Jackson, poised to rewrite the record books, has already made a significant impact with his rushing abilities and passing skills. Allen, with his impressive rushing touchdowns and passing records, is establishing himself as one of the best dual-threat quarterbacks in the league. Wilson, known for his consistency and leadership, has put up impressive numbers both as a passer and a rusher, solidifying his place among the greats.
As the debate continues over who is the greatest dual-threat quarterback in NFL history, it is essential to consider the impact that these players have had on the game and how they have redefined the quarterback position. Each era has produced exceptional talent, with players like Young, Vick, Newton, Jackson, and others leaving a lasting legacy on the sport. Ultimately, the answer to this question may vary depending on personal preferences and criteria for greatness, but one thing is clear: dual-threat quarterbacks have changed the game and will continue to do so for years to come.