Tyreek Hill, the wide receiver for the Miami Dolphins, recently shared his list of the top five NFL quarterbacks in the league, based on his personal opinion. Unsurprisingly, he ranked his former teammate Patrick Mahomes of the Kansas City Chiefs as the best quarterback in the league. Hill and Mahomes had a successful partnership during their time together, with Hill praising Mahomes’ skills on the field.
Following Mahomes, Hill placed his current quarterback Tua Tagovailoa in the second spot on his list. Despite acknowledging that there are other quarterbacks who may be considered better than Tagovailoa, Hill’s loyalty to his teammate shines through in his ranking. Tagovailoa, although still developing his career, has shown promise as a young quarterback for the Dolphins.
Hill then listed Lamar Jackson of the Baltimore Ravens as the third-best quarterback, highlighting Jackson’s achievements as a former regular-season MVP. Dak Prescott of the Dallas Cowboys secured the fourth spot on Hill’s list, with his leadership skills recognized despite facing challenges in the playoffs.
The most surprising addition to Hill’s list was Baker Mayfield of the Tampa Bay Buccaneers in the fifth position. Mayfield’s performance has been inconsistent throughout his career, but Hill’s assessment of his skills places him among the top quarterbacks currently playing in the NFL.
In contrast, CBS Sports experts had a different ranking for the top five NFL quarterbacks heading into 2024. According to their analysis, Patrick Mahomes still held the top spot, followed by Brock Purdy of the San Francisco 49ers, Josh Allen of the Buffalo Bills, Joe Burrow of the Cincinnati Bengals, and C.J. Stroud of the Houston Texans.
It is interesting to note the variations between Hill’s personal ranking and the expert analysis provided by CBS Sports. While Hill’s list reflected his personal experiences and preferences, the CBS Sports ranking considered a broader range of factors to assess the top quarterbacks in the league. Ultimately, quarterback rankings can vary based on individual perspectives and criteria used for evaluation in the competitive landscape of the NFL.